WYTS: New York Jets. Original post here.
There’s a lot of history in New York, and we’d need a lot
more NFL teams to cover every single big riot in this area. There's at least five important ones that deserve their own entries. I regret not picking Stonewall for one of the two I covered in retrospect... Maybe we need a bonus episode at the end.
One of the two riots was the New York City Draft Riots of 1863,
one of the largest civil unrest events in American history, maybe the biggest, unless you count the Civil War itself. You might remember this riot sabotaging the ending fight between Amsterdam and Bill the Butcher in Gangs of New York, a
Scorsese movie too good to be spoiled by a terrible DiCaprio
performance.
Through its history up until the Civil War, New
York always had a… complicated relationship with
slavery, let’s say. It was a major
slave
trading port in the 1700s. One of the first riots in American history happened right here in 1712 when about 23 African slaves attempted a revolt for their freedom, only to be shot down, and many were executed in horrible manner by being burnt on the stake. A second riot happened in 1741, which either was an aborted slave revolt or just an imagined conspiracy that got out of hand, which also ended in mass executions. After the Revolution and slavery's ending in New York, the city had no problem doing business with the cotton plantations, making a lot of money in the process. Lehman
Brothers, the infamous 2008 Great Recession bank, got started as a
cotton trading firm before moving to NY in 1858, for example. These
trading ties were so important some business leaders wanted New York City itself to
secede as a neutral free city when the Civil War
broke out.
Meanwhile, as Scorsese and DiCaprio teach us, there was a
huge
immigrant population, especially important being Irish immigrants. The Five Points were an infamous slum, so infamous that European tourists would take a visit as part of their American vacations, notably Charles Dickens. The Catholic population, largely Irish, were expanding rapidly in 1840s, thanks to the famine at home, and this brought all sorts of social troubles. You have the gangs of course, .DiCaprio's Amsterdam character did not actually found the Dead Rabbits, they a major Irish gang well before then. They would have their biggest battle with their rivals, the Bowery Boys in 1857, a riot that killed 8 people. (There's a lot of riots in NYC! Did I mentioned that?) Many cities on the East Coast in 1800s had these sorts of gang problems, especially in Baltimore, we'll circle back to this later, get hype, Ravens fans.
Tammany Hall, the political machine that is noted as one of the most corrupt in American history, actually did a lot to create a place in NYC for these people. I think Nativist bigotry ended up writing a lot of the history on the old-style political machines. You could be right off the boat but still have a personal relationship with a person in power who could affect change for the better. Which made a lot of the older Protestant "natives" very angry. You could do a lot worse in the vast and varied unseemly history of American politics, let's say. Also, it is not like New York got less corrupt after the machine politics ended, just the government started working for business interests, not voter patronage.
We must mention that there was a large free black
population in Manhattan of about 12,500. That is not enormous in a city of 800,000 plus, but their position at the bottom of society was now a
radical question thanks to a war over slavery, the Emancipation
Proclamation, and the rise
of the Republican party. Republicans were in opposition to Tammany Democrats. There was a lot of fear in NYC that newly-freed slaves would suddenly crowd into Manhattan and weaken the job market. Racism does not need a logic, but labor concerns are a major factor in all of this. (We'll get back to this a lot.)
July 1863 is a huge month for Civil
War nerds: Lee is invading
Pennsylvania, itching for a fight he’s going to lose, Grant is closing
the noose around Vicksburg, and the third major battle is right here in
Manhattan. Tensions have been broiling in the city since March, when Congress passed the Enrollment Act, the first wide-national conscription in American history. Before this, Union Army regiments had been either volunteer or conscripted by their local states (we won't really have the uniform federal army you recognize today until the 20th century). The Civil War was not terribly popular in NYC by either the immigrants or the older WASP crowds, and it is not getting more popular with an impending draft event on July 11th. Copperhead Democrats became increasingly furious that New York will have
to sacrifice itself further for a Republican and anti-slavery war. Newspapers begin publishing hysterical anti-war and very racist screeds - never
a good sign for civil unrest incidents.
Most importantly, the city's garrison is very undermanned as they had some problems on Cemetery Ridge and Little Round Top to deal with.
The first day of the drafting actually went fine,. It's the second day of drafting, July 13th,
1863, where the city exploded. This is an interesting event for a lot of reasons, one of which is many of the rioters were Irish, but so were the police, the heavily-Irish and brand new Metropolitan
Police led by Superintendent John Kennedy (not that one). By the way, this police force had only been in existence for a few years, they had a full-on gang battle with the older Municipal Police Force in 1857 - there are many many riots in NYC's history.
But let's focus: the revolt starts at about 10:00 AM on a Monday at 3rd Ave and 47th Street, in the NYC 9th Provost building. This is actually to the north of the famous Five Points. The Five Points, despite what the great historian, Martin Scorsese tells us, did not really get that involved in this event. Lower Manhattan had some chaos, but the fighting was centered in Midtown. About 500 angry men, led by a fire engine company nicknamed the Black Joke, start throwing rocks and paving stones through the windows. They smash into the draft, taking control of the room, burning everything. The volunteer firefighters have ironically become arsonists, the whole building burns down. They also fight off any other firemen who come by. Superintendent Kennedy arrived on the scene with his Metro Police. He's recognized even out of uniform by the rioters, and Kennedy is nearly assassinated, with 70 stab wounds. At this point, the mob begins a march around the city, just destroying whatever they really felt like. The city's arsenal fell by the late-afternoon.
Their targets during these riots were numerous and diverse. Most tragic would be the Colored Orphan Asylum on 44th Street, which was a major charity organization. The 237 orphans were able to escape thanks to the police fighting back the mob, but the building was looted and burnt down. The offices of the abolitionist paper, The New York Tribune were also destroyed. The pro-Republican, New York Times (what else has changed, am I right?) survived thanks to Henry Raymond, its founder, personally defending the Gray Lady with gatling guns, first appearance of these weapons, not the last. A lot of this also just became an old-fashioned racial pogrom, with random black people lynched and hanged, one poor man was set on hanged and set on fire. The black tenements by the waterfront were burnt. The white wealthy were not spared either, especially if you were a known-Republican. Brooks Brothers was looted.
Fresh Union troops would not make it to Manhattan until Wednesday, the 15th. Lee's army had retreated back into Virginia, ending any farfetched hope of a Southern victory, so troops were available to recapture Gotham. These new soldiers began pushing into rioting areas. By Friday there were 6,000 soldiers in the city and the Draft Riots were crushed.
The final death toll in in dispute. Some reports say just 18 deaths, which sounds impossibly low. Another has 120, but then you'll find wildly high numbers like 1,200 killed. Ultimately, nobody knows and until very recently, whatever casualty numbers you read from civil disturbances or other kinds of disasters are going to be total guesses. These estimates are usually on the low-end as the governments involved undercount people they do not care about. I would not be that surprised if the death toll from the Draft Riots are well into the hundreds. It was very bad, the worst riot in New York's history by far. And there were a lot of riots.
One part of the story I was unhappy to learn was how
successful this pogrom actually was. The black population of Manhattan dropped to pre-1820
levels, several thousand left and never returned. Many of the survivors migrated to Brooklyn or other areas. You can still see these racial lines in Manhattan today. Bobby Womack's 'Across
110th Street' is a banger and an accurate picture of the demographic lines even today. Harlem was not even settled yet in the 1860s, that would be a brand new development when it had its Renaissance in the 20th century.
The planned draft that sparked this whole riot actually was completed a few weeks later without incident. President Lincoln appointed General John Dix to make sure New York City finished its conscription process. In the end, fewer New Yorkers got drafted anyway than the panicked Copperheads imagined. The South lost the war, in case you didn't know, and New York just kept on making tons and tons of money without needing a slave economy to drive its engines.