"Super 8" is the kind of movie that so almost works its painful. Somewhere inside this movie (actually roughly the first thirty minutes) is a really good film that I'd recommend without a thought. Half of this movie is a classic "Stand By Me" story of children growing up in the American suburbs. Someplace else is a monster movie. These two concepts do not belong together in this movie. I really don't know why J.J. Abrams thought to try to remake "E.T." by replacing the alien with a monster that eats people. But then, I also don't know why Abrams constantly refused all movie to ever let you see the monster. Its a decent kid's movie, a horrible awful monster movie.Me and J.J. Abrams don't have a very close relationship. For one, I've never met the man and I don't believe we've ever been in the same state at one time. But also, the movies he makes are never things I ever like. "Cloverfield" comes back again and again on this blog as easily the most infuriating SciFi movie that's been made in the last decade. You barely ever see the monster, shakey-camera, all the best action sequences happen off-camera, the movie explains nothing, the characters are awful, etc. Then there's "Lost", a terrible show that pretended to be deep by conjuring up armor of mysteries and clues, only for it all fall down and eventually prove to be completely hollow and pointless. "Star Trek" was a straight-forward space opera movie, and I can ultimate respect that. I didn't really love "Star Trek", but it was okay. For some reason or another Abrams decides to bring back some of the worst features of "Cloverfield" here.
"Super 8", however, is a much much better movie than "Cloverfield" thanks entirely to its cast. J.J. Abrams shines in directing the small emotional kid's story, with expert casting and a brilliant script. Then he fails completely when it comes to the monster movie. The love letter to late 70s/early 80s small town life is far more effective than the love letter to the SciFi films of the period. Why did this need to be a monster movie at all?



