My movie theme for May was Sports Movies. Like last month when I did
musicals, I wanted to focus on an aspect of social life that the plague mostly
has taken away from us. In an alternate reality, with perhaps a functioning
government, I would have seen the New York Yankees play the Mariners this month. Instead, nobody saw the
Yankees or the Mariners. We are all poorer for it. But, I think this will be my last wistful theme. I'm getting a bit depressed mourning normal life one entertainment at a time.
Anyway, as genres go, Sports Films have never exactly been a favorite of mine.
The stress and excitement of a real sporting event is much more dramatic
than a fictionalized version. No screenwriter can replicate the sheer joy I
had when the Broncos defense held Tom Brady twice at the goal line in
the 2016 AFC Championship. I've never felt worse in my life than back in 2004 when the
Yankees blew a 3-0 lead in a playoff series against the Red Sox. I was twelve
years old and until then, did not actually know what sadness was. A movie needs a structure, it needs arcs, it needs meaning. Real sports are random statistical noise upon which we add the arcs and meaning. That's what creates the excitement. You can't manufacture that.
So ultimately if you're going to make a great sports movie, it cannot actually be about
the sport. I know in the real world there is a selection of people who demand
athletes only play ball and then shut up. You can usually find those guys
calling in to ESPN radio to complain about Odell Beckham Jr. and they all
sound like your racist uncle. But it is really the stories behind the
ball-playing that make for good drama. The balls don't matter, the cultural weight we give to the balls matter. Winning and losing is interesting, but
not exactly proof of any justice or your worthiness as a person. Robert
Kraft owns the Patriots and is a billionaire. He wins every day, and he's a
piece of fucking shit.
Interesting humanity does not come from winning or
losing. Heroes lose, monsters win and that doesn't make for good fiction. I don't care about the home runs or the triple doubles as an abstract feat of strength. I care about the story behind the home runs and triple doubles. So never shut
up and play ball.




